Thomas J. Nevin at the Citizen's Arch, 8 January 1868

Royal Visit to Hobart by HRH Prince ALFRED, Duke of Edinburgh 1868
Thos J. NEVIN's cdv's of the Citizen's Arch 1868
Photograph ALBUMS of scenes and children gifted to the Prince 1868
Captain GOLDSMITH's vehicular ferry "Kangaroo" on fire 1868
F. J. PATERSON (attr) reprints as stereo of Thos J. Nevin's cdv the Citizen's Arch 1890

1868: a busy year for Thomas J. Nevin



Above: cropped detail of carte-de-visite below:
The Citizens' Arch, Hobart, Tasmania
Erected for the visit of HRH Prince Alfred, Duke of Edinburgh
Photographer: Thomas J. Nevin, 8 January 1868
Private collection (ex DSFB) October 2023)

Citizens Arch 1868 Nevin photo

Subject: The Citizens' Arch, design and decorations by Charles E. Walch, paid for by citizens' subscriptions to honour the visit to Tasmania by HRH Prince Alfred, Duke of Edinburgh. Inscription on arch - "The Citizens Greet You."
Photographer: Thomas J. Nevin (1842-1923)
Location and date: Liverpool Street, Hobart, Tasmania, 8 January 1868
Format: albumen print photograph, carte de visite landscape format, 63 x 103 mm (mount)
Verso: bears the signature of "Thos J Nevin" in sepia ink, written in his usual orthographic style and contemporaneous with the date of photographic capture and print, January 1868.
Details: this is one of two consecutive images of the same scene taken by Nevin within a minute of each other, the second printed here as a cdv, and both intended to be printed together as a stereograph (Nevin's original stereograph may have been misattributed to F. J. Paterson - see below).
Condition: crisp, clean, ash burn at top edge, no foxing.
Provenance: acquired for sale by Douglas Stewart Fine Books, Melbourne, Victoria from the estate of photographer Joyce Evans (1929-2019).
Copyright: Sold by DSFB, October 2023 to private collector. Permission to reproduce here.

Citizens Arch 1868 Nevin photo

Thomas J. Nevin's signature: "Thos J Nevin"
Thomas James Nevin printed and signed the verso of this photograph in the same sepia ink used to develop it, and probably within hours of returning to his studio from capturing the scene in Liverpool Street on the morning of the Prince's procession through the Citizen's Arch, Tuesday, 8 January 1868. To meet an anticipated high demand for souvenirs by the thousands of people attending the event, he had left little time on that day to imprint the verso with one of his studio stamps or labels. His signature remained largely unchanged from this example in 1868 to his signatures on the birth registrations of six  of his seven children, 1872-1888. The one birth registration he did not sign was that of his first-born son to wife Elizabeth Rachael Day, whom they named the same as his father - Thomas James Nevin jnr in May 1874 - signed by her father Captain James Day while Nevin was away on business at the Port Arthur prison.



Above: Photographer Thomas J. Nevin's signature on the birth registration of their first child, daughter Mary (May) Florence Elizabeth Nevin, 29 June 1872. His first name "Thomas" was abbreviated to "Thos" and second name "James" to "Jas", both presumably written first, followed by an artistic calligraphic flourish on the "N" for Nevin which appears to start from the front at "Thos" and flies over the frst two names to finish as "Nevin". Note the 18th century copperplate script for "P" on "Photographer" in the Rank or Profession of Father column.



Above: Nevin, Mary Florence Elizabeth
Record Type: Births
Gender: Female
Father: Nevin, Thomas James
Mother: Day, Elizabeth Rachel
Date of birth:19 May 1872
Registered: Hobart
Registration year:1872
Record ID:NAME_INDEXES:974599
Resource:RGD33/1/10/ no 2599
Source: Tasmanian Names Indexes TAHO
Link: https://stors.tas.gov.au/RGD33-1-10-p373j2k

See more examples of photographer Thomas James Nevin's signature here: https://tasmanianphotographer.blogspot.com/2014/10/thomas-j-nevin-at-new-town-studio-to.html

Nevin & Smith partnership
In late 1865 Thomas J. Nevin moved his practice from Kangaroo Valley (Hobart) where he was selling stereographs out of the New Town Post Office, to the studio leased by Alfred Bock at 140 Elizabeth St. Hobart Town. On Bock's insolvency and imminent departure to Victoria in 1866, Nevin acquired the lease on the studio, including the glass house, furnishings, stock in trade and business name, "The City Photographic Establishment". A joint lease with the Biggs family included a residence and shop next to the studio at 138 Elizabeth Street. In 1867 Nevin formed a partnership with photographer Robert Smith, operating from the studio as the firm Nevin & Smith. Their studio marks, stamps and labels included a rare, distinctive stamp featuring the Prince of Wales' blazon of three feathers and a coronet, banded with the German "ICH DIEN" (I Serve).

This delicately coloured carte-de-visite in a buff oval mount of an unidentified bearded man in semi-profile wearing a summer check-pattern jacket was taken in January 1868 during the visit of HRH Prince Alfred, Duke of Edinburgh. On the verso is the stamp featuring the Prince's blazon used by Thomas Nevin and Robert Smith in partnership during the Royal visit.

Portrait by Nevin & Smith 1868Verso Portrait by Nevin & Smith 1868

Carte-de-visite of bearded young man in check jacket, hand tinted, 1868
Photographers: Nevin & Smith. Late Bock's, 140 Elizabeth St. Hobart Town
Verso bears the Prince of Wales' blazon of three feathers and coronet, p
Printed during the visit of Prince Alfred, January 1868
Courtesy of ©The Liam Peters Collection 2010.

In anticipation of robust sales during the visit of Prince Alfred in January 1868, Thomas J. Nevin advertised extensively in the Tasmanian Times. He submitted photographs of streetscapes and portraits of children at the request of the Prince Alfred Preparation Committee along with a dozen other photographers, a selection of which was printed in souvenir albums to be presented to the Duke on his departure (see newspaper articles below). Thomas Nevin's partnership with Robert Smith was dissolved in late February 1868, a month after the Duke's visit by his solicitor, W. R. Giblin (later Attorney-General and Premier), on Smith's decision to leave Hobart and set up his own photographic studio in Goulburn NSW.

Tuesday, 8th January 1868
The atmosphere ... was rather sultry during the early part of the day, but towards noon a refreshing sea breeze sprang up, which soon crested the river with foam, and although it rendered the scene rather difficult for the photographers by reason of the waving of the banners and the movement of the various decorations, it was extremely refreshing, and contributed greatly to the pleasure of all concerned in the reception. Speaking of the photographers, we may mention that the gentlemen engaged by the reception commissioners have succeeded in producing very creditable views of the procession, both on large plates and in stereoscopic style. [Mercury, 8 January 1868]

By 9 o'clock on the morning of Tuesday 8th January 1868, Thomas J. Nevin had set up his cameras in Liverpool Street, Hobart, facing the Citizen's Arch as the crowds began forming in anticipation of the Duke of Edinburgh passing through on his way to Government House in Macquarie Street at midday. He may have been working on commission for the Citizens' Arch designer and decorator, Charles E. Walch, partner in the family firm Walch & Sons Co., publishers of the annual Walch's Almanac and regular importers of photographic supplies.

Well before the Duke's arrival, Thomas Nevin took two photographs (extant) of the street and the Citizen's Arch, each a minute or so apart from the same spot. Both photographs have survived. He would print a single image as a carte-de-visite of one of the captures as well as pasting the two slightly different captures of the scene side by side on a double mount to be viewed as a true stereograph with a stereoscopic viewer. His first photograph captured a man near the (viewer's) left side of the arch (see stereograph below with Paterson attribution). The second photograph taken a minute or so later captured the same man having walked from the left side of the arch to the centre of the road, presumably to greet oncoming traffic.

This second photograph of the street and a man now closer to the centre of the road beneath the arch carries Thomas Nevin's signature on verso in sepia. It survived in modern times as a single image carte-de-visite in the estate of the late Joyce Evans (1929-2019), photographer and friend of Professor Joan Kerr whose farewell lecture at Sydney University on retirement in 1994 included an affectionate appraisal of the work of Thomas J. Nevin as the photographer of Tasmania's "convicts" in the 1870s.



The Citizens' Arch, Hobart, Tasmania: man near centre of the arch
Erected for the visit of HRH Prince Alfred, Duke of Edinburgh
Photographer: Thomas J. Nevin, 8 January 1868 (private collection - see above)

The first photograph which Thomas Nevin took a minute or so before the second of the same scene in Liverpool Street shows a man standing under the left side of the Citizens' Arch. This first image has survived on a stereographic mount in the collection of the Cox family (held at the Archives Office of Tasmania), printed as a stereograph and attributed to F. J. Paterson. But it is not a true stereograph (see below). The same image was printed twice from Nevin's single first negative he took of the man standing under the left side of the arch before the man moved towards the centre of the road. Those same two prints from this first negative were then pasted to a square format stereograph mount to make the whole appear to be a true stereograph. Each image on left and right in this so-called stereograph are from the same capture and negative, whereas for a stereograph to give a true 3D experience, two distinct photographs are printed from two separate negatives (if a single lens camera is used) and then pasted side by side, with more detail of the scene, usually in the right image showing at the right side margin where the camera was moved to the right.



Photograph - stereogram - Duke of Edinburgh's visit, Welcome arch, "The Citizen's Greet You", shows side of Beaumont's Family Hotel, Liverpool Street and "Graham's",
Photographer F.J Paterson
Item Number: NS6904/1/34
Start Date: 01 Jan 1868
End Date: 31 Dec 1868
Source: Tasmanian Archives
Creating Agency: Cox, Weymouth and Miller Family (NG1640)
Series: Photographs collected by the Cox Family (NS6904)
View online: https://stors.tas.gov.au/NS6904-1-34



Detail: The Citizen's Arch, Liverpool Street, Hobart Tasmania
Single image from right side of stereograph
Photographer: F.J Paterson (attributed)
Item Number: NS6904/1/34
Start Date: 01 Jan 1868
End Date: 31 Dec 1868
Source: Tasmanian Archives

Differences
The two photographs - the cdv carrying Thomas Jas. Nevin's signature verso taken after the image in the so-called stereograph which is attributed to F. J. Paterson of the same scene - are slightly different. In Paterson's there is a woman with a cart shielded by an umbrella on the pavement to the left, whereas in the Nevin print there are several carts and men in the same spot. In the Paterson print, the man standing under the arch is closer to left column of the arch, whereas in the Nevin photograph the man appears to have walked closer to the centre of the road in order to greet the approaching van. The van in the distance is further away in the stereo image (attr. Paterson's) than in the cdv image (Nevin's). The sky and foreground in Nevin's cdv appears to have been cropped for printing, whereas the stereograph print shows more of both. These differences raise questions of both printing techniques from different cameras and lenses, as well as attribution: was there just one photographer present who took two separate captures just minutes apart? Or were both Nevin and Paterson present together in the exact same spot from where each took almost identical photographs, one within minutes of the other? One valued opinion (at DSFB) very much doubts that, opting for Nevin's as the sole attribution for both images.

The stereograph bears no photographer's mark, imprint or studio stamp. It was donated to the Archives of Tasmania as part of the Cox family collections and given an attribution to F. J. Paterson, who operated a studio at 53 Argyle St. Hobart between 1864-1869 (Davies & Stanbury The Mechanical Eye in Australia, Oxford University Press 1986.) but was much better known later in the 1890s as a marine photographer and assistant secretary to the Photographic and Arts Association. F. J. Paterson may have acquired the first negative Nevin took of the Citizen's Arch from Nevin's own collection of commercial negatives which he passed on to Samuel Clifford when ceasing commercial photography temporarily on joining the civil service as resident Hobart Town Hall keeper with family, 1876-1880. In turn, on Clifford's retirement in 1878, his own negatives and collections, including those of Nevin's, were acquired by the Anson Bros and subsequently by John Watt Beattie who reprinted the work of these earlier photographers without attribution. The first negative Nevin created of the scene which has survived as a stereograph, and possibly misattributed to F. J. Paterson, may have survived therefore from Beattie's collections, perhaps even been reprinted as a stereograph in 1899-1900 in anticipation of the Duke and Duchess of York's Royal Visit in 1901. A proposal by its original decorator C. J. Walch to re-erect the Citizen's Arch for the occasion would have included printing historical as well as contemporary photographic souvenirs ahead of the visit.

As was Thomas Nevin's practice, he used different formats when producing photographs for important public occasions. For the VIP visitors' trip to Adventure Bay in 1872, for example, he printed the first of two consecutive captures taken on the spot of the visitor group as a landscape carte-de-visite, and with the second image produced a stereograph with both slightly different images pasted side by side on two types of mount: arched above both images for one item, circular or binocular for another. He would also take and print two photographs of the same sitter in his studio, leaving one without a studio mark, and signing or printing his commercial stamp on the verso of the other, chosen according to his clients' preferences (examples are held in the TMAG collection). Given two images were taken of the same street scene of a man under the Citizen's within a minute of each other, the print bearing Thomas J. Nevin's signature verso was either the one he intended to keep, or the one he intended to include with the second capture to print as a stereograph, perhaps with the Nevin & Smith stamp featuring the Prince's blazon, but failed to proceed with using his studio's mark because Robert Smith would be departing the partnership in a matter of weeks.

Put together, the views in sequence as Thomas Nevin would have photographed them:





There is a narrative here: the first image shows a man waiting on the left side of the arch, and on seeing a van and horses approaching in the second image he walks toward the centre of the road to greet them.

Some time later, as the entire procession with the Prince and his official entourage comes into view, large crowds now gathered on both sides of Liverpool Street watch and wave and cheer. The moment the procession passes under the arch, an unnamed photographer skilfully captures every aspect of the excited scene: the barking and running of the dogs, the skittishness of the horses, the billowing of women's dresses, the flapping of flags, and the flurry of flowers and dust. The air is filled with tumultuous cheers and applause as everyone surges towards the Prince. Except one man. There he is, the same watchful man photographed by Thomas Nevin a few hours earlier. He's back at his post, squeezed up against the left side of the arch's column by the crowds. Perhaps he was a Special Constable in plain clothes enlisted for the occasion, just as Thomas Nevin was made Special Constable in 1879 during the visit of the Canadian renegade Catholic priest, Charles Chiniquy.

Citizens Arch Hobart 1868

Description: Photograph - Street view of decorations for the visit of Duke of Edinburgh in January
Item Number: PH30/1/3320
Start Date: 01 Jan 1868
Format: photograph [unattributed]
Creating  Agency: Unidentified Creating Agency (XX1)
Archives Office of Tasmania
View online: https://stors.tas.gov.au/PH30-1-3320

Not only did Charles E. Walch publish again in the Mercury of 2 April, 1901 the exact same paragraph about the Citizen's Arch that he published in the Mercury on 24 December 1867, he would have displayed at the family's business premises a collection of the original photographs and memorabilia of his beautiful floral designs for the 1868 arch in anticipation of another success when the Citizens' Arch was again to be erected in honour of the Duke and Duchess of York's visit, 2-6 July 1901, this time in Macquarie Street.



'Citizens Arch,' Macquarie Street, 2-6 July 1901
Item Number: NS5742/1/38
Creating Agency: Edward Swarbreck Hall and Family (NG308)
View online:https://libraries.tas.gov.au/Record/Archives/NS5742-1-38

Timeline: the Citizens' Arch, 1867-1901

Newspaper Reports

4 December 1867: LETTER from Charles Walch
THE CITIZENS' ARCH.
TO THE EDITOR OF THE MERCURY,
SIR-In reading over the report of the proceedings of the Municipal Council published in this morning's Mercury there are two inaccuracies which I shall be glad if you will allow me to correct. In the first place the letter read at the Council Board, from the secretary of the Citizens' Arch Committee, is stated to be from Mr. Creswell. This is not correct ; Mr. Creswell is the indefatigable secretary of the Citizens' Reception Committee, but Mr. Charles E. Walch has the honour of being the secretary of the Citizens' Arch Committee. In the second place it is stated that my application to the Mayor and Aldermen was for a grant towards erecting the arch. This is the second error, for my application was for a grant towards decorating the arch, the Prince Alfred Preparation Committee having decided to erect the arch for which a model has been accepted leaving its decoration entirely in the hands of the citizens, and for which a small committee, in the name of the citizens generally, have made themselves responsible.

I am very glad to say that the design for this arch (the model is now on view at Wellington Bridge has been approved by all who have seen it), and that the few citizens who have been asked to contribute towards the cost of the decorations have done so most liberally. I am sorry that the Mayor and Aldermen, in their corporate capacity, could not see their way clear to give a grant either in money or in labour' towards the decoration of the citizens' arch ; however, it is gratifying to see that they are prepared to do the next best thing, and that is to subscribe liberally themselves. I have urged the erection of this citizens' arch on the Corporation, because nowhere on the route of the Prince's public entry into and passage through the city, will there be the slightest visible result of our having a Corporation at all excepting of course the pleasure that he will have in seeing the Mayor and Aldermen themselves.

The whole matter stands thus. There has been collected and promised up to the present time about sixty pounds ; but to decorate the arch worthily will cost at least one hundred pounds, leaving forty pounds yet to be collected. To get together this little sum of forty pounds, I now I confidently look to His Worship the Mayor, the Aldermen, and those citizens who have not yet been asked to contribute ; so that if in the vastness of their assembled crowds, and the gorgeousness of their general display, her sister colonies ease Tasmania completely into the shade, who in her turn will be able to boast of a triumph of artistic and decorative art in her " citizens' arch'."

I am, dear sir,
Faithfully yours,
CHARLES E. WALCH.
December 3rd, 1867

Source: THE CITIZENS ARCH. (1867, December 4). The Mercury p. 2.
Link: https://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article8849312

7 December 1867: FUNDING the Citizens' Arch
At a meeting of the Citizens' Reception Committee at Hobart Town on Wednesday, subscription lists were submitted representing £200. Another £100 is expected. It seems that the arch termed the Citizens' Arch is to be erected at the expense of the Government, and the only part to be played by the citizens is the decorating of it with flowers, designs, &., which it is expected will cost no less than £100. We are informed that in Melbourne the artificial flowers alone of one of the arches cost upwards of £200. The Citizens' Committee have appointed three subcommittees to carry out the details of the objects contemplated by the Citizens' Committee, viz., a Citizens' Ball, the erection of an emblematic arch, and a banquet to the crew of the Galatea. The model of the citizens arch, at Hobart Town, represents a four faced structure with the principal face towards Liverpool-street as seen from Murray-street. It will start from the four corners and will present a pretty effect. It will be in the shape of a dome highly ornamented with appropriate drapery, flowers, lamps, &, and have on its principal face an appropriate motto. The top will be surmounted with a huge crown composed of flowers.
Source: RECEPTION OF PRINCE ALFRED. (1867, December 7). Launceston Examiner p. 5.
Link: https://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article36647697

28 December 1867: HUMOUR by Punch
This article's attempt to disparage the elaborate preparations for the Duke's visit may have passed for humour of the day. The journalist writing this for the Hobart Town Punch spared the Citizen's Arch of criticism but not the Emblematic Arch. He ridiculed in particular the Ode of Welcome written by Mrs Louisa Anne Meredith intended to be sung by five thousand children.



TRANSCRIPT
The Arches.
SOME skeletons of what are intended to be ornamental structures blockup the thoroughfares, and look sadly miserable, as the wind whistles through their bare ribs. We don't know how these skeletons will look when" clothed with evergreens and flowers, but at present "triumphal" is about the last adjective proper to characterise them. The Emblematic Arch on the Wharf is an idea of a good kind, and appropriately founded on oil-butts, signifying that Tasmania is the butt of the colonies and of the empire, an Ultima Thule indeed. We believe that beside the wool bales on top, there are to be other objects characteristic of Tasmanian commerce, amongst others, a Truss of Hay cut open to exhibit a large stone which takes up a good part of its interior, some bags of sour Chilian flour mixed with plaster of Paris and branded "Best Tasmanian Flour," some tins of boiled carrots sweetened with sugar, labelled "Fine Tasmanian Jam" from a well-known Hebrew firm, a stranger from Victoria as he appeared when taken in and done for by Hobart Town lodging house keepers and Cabmen. These will form a striking emblem of some lucrative branches of Tasmanian Commerce. Then a few models of the manufactories and mines of Tasmania, the Pyrolignite Works, the Seymour Coal Mines, Fingal Companies, and others, showing in a striking manner the energy and perseverance of the people. On the top three enormous barrels of beer from the breweries of the Mayors of Hobart Town and Launceston and our ex-Mayor, this being the only really flourishing trade in Tasmania. On these barrels will be a group of native youth in various lounging attitudes, smoking — with some City Arabs and one or two country skullbankers. This group will typify the strongest characteristics of a large part of our energetic population. His H. H. the Prince will then get a bird's eye view of Tasmania. The citizens' Arch, called so because the Government have erected it, is a great credit to the town and a feather in the cap of the energetic individuals to whom we owe it. A brilliant illumination of arches would quite cut out all other displays, even the magnificent star of Messrs Salier & Co.

The Ode of Welcome. WE have said so much about this, that we have little more to add. It will be enough to say that the way it is sung does more than justice to the words of Mrs. Meredith and the music of Packer, for the less that is heard of either the better. The verses have not even the merit which so many other nonsense verses have, that of decent rhythm. On the whole we prefer the National Anthem, and we think the Prince will be of the same opinion, if he hears either from the assembled children. The conductor has snubbed every one who has attempted to help him with the children; he wanted all the glory, and we think no one will care to share with him what he will get when the production is 'performed' before the Prince. His H.H. R. will call him and the performers a Pack of ninnies.
The Platforms !!! ARE by no means the least brilliant part of the display intended to do honor to the Sailor Prince. They are, for the most part, constructed of colonial hardwood, which being in the rough, gives them a pleasingly rustic appearance, and is likely to conduce in no small measure to the comfort of their occupants. That slight spice of danger too, which is generally so much appreciated by the public, is not wholly absent, and lends a zest to the enjoyment of those adventurous spirits who feel a pleasure in paying their shilling or half-crown for the privilege of balancing themselves for a couple of hours or so on a couple of inches of batten, at a distance of from ten to thirty feet from the ground. Messrs. Bromby and Cox would like it to be as generally known as possible, that in their advertisement, which appeared in our last number, it was omitted to be stated that their platforms are all arranged as locomotives, being mounted on wheels, and travelling upon rails. By this ingenious arrangement they can be run back after the Prince has passed, and will be available for the ceremony of Laying the Foundation Stone of the New Cathedral. It is suggested that people of an economical turn of mind should take seats, for the procession, on these platforms, as by laying in a stock of sandwiches. &c., there would be no necessity for them to move until after the day of the Laying the Foundation Stone, and they would be thus enabled to view both ceremonials for the same money. N.B.—Bed-gowns similar to those to be worn by the choir on the latter occasion may be had at reasonable rates on application to Messrs. Bromby, Cox, or Hunter.
Source: The Arches, Hobart Town Punch Saturday 28 December 1867, page 8
Link: https://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article232935336

8 January 1868: STATE RECEPTION and CITIZENS' ARCH



TRANSCRIPT - excerpt
THE DUKE OF EDINBURGH IN TASMANIA.
THE STATE RECEPTION.

Yesterday will be marked as a red-letter day in the history of Tasmania, being that upon which the first scion of English royalty ever set foot upon her shores. The importance attached by a loyal populace to the event was most unmistakable, and if the demonstration of affectionate greeting which was made on the occasion was in any degree loss imposing than that shown in richer colonies, it is on account of the smaller proportions of our city, and from no want of genuine liberality and loyal feeling on the part of our citizens. In introducing a detailed report of the state ceremony of the day, it would be difficult to convey any adequate idea of the genuine enthusiasm which pervaded all the arrangements, suffice it to say that from the moment of His Royal Highness's landing until his arrival at Government House, the welcome which greeted him was spontaneous, heartfelt, and sincere. Those of our readers who know the city will be aware that at sundown on Monday evening the arrangements for the reception were far from complete, and men were employed in some cases throughout the night in perfecting them. At day dawn gangs of men were at work on the various arches, in hoisting flags on the wharves, and otherwise completing the arrangements, and it was quite 12 o'clock before all was ready. By nine o'clock in the morning the streets were crowded with people who had turned out to view the general decorations, and to make sure of their positions for obtaining a good sight of the procession. The centre of attraction seemed to be the public buildings, and from thence to the wharf ; and many thousands of persons had assembled in those localities at an early hour. The stands erected in various parts of the city were scarcely so well patronised as might have been expected. Those erected by the government, by Messrs. Walch, and by private persons on the wharves, were well filled, but the others were far from crowded. It was about eleven o'clock when the populace really began to muster in force, and then the wharf stands were fairly rushed, the piles of timber also became superior points of view, and every available point from which the landing and progress of the procession in its earlier stages could be witnessed were eagerly seized upon. From the river and wharves, wherever a clear view of the town could be obtained, the sight was most imposing ; and seen from the top of the hill behind Franklin Square, the marshalling of the procession was a most magnificent sight. The dense mass of heads moving about in the plateau below, the waving of the flags' and banners borne by the friendly societies, the red shirts of the fire-men, and the emblematic arch with its two whaleboats manned by crews of native youths in red shirts and sailor hats ; and beyond all the long clear space, with the dais for the accommodation of the Mayor and Corporation standing out in bold relief, dotted here and there by groups of officials in uniform, and the clergy in their robes of office, besides little knots of private citizens ; the whole scene enlivened by the regular lines of scarlet coats, white belts, and glittering bayonets, distinguishing the guard of honor, combined to form a scene of surpassing brilliancy. Nor have we half described the appearance of the crowd from this point of view. The natural beauties of the harbour added much to the grandeur of its effect. The wharves flanked by lines of vessels dressed in all their colors, and all crowded with eager spectators, and the glittering river with the noble ship riding at anchor, and resplendent with bunting, formed a glorious contrast, and combined to complete a scene scarcely equalled in the pages of fairy romance. The weather during the morning was everything that could be desired, although dark threatening clouds hung over the mountain, fore-boding rain. The atmosphere, too, was rather sultry during the early part of the day, but towards noon a refreshing sea breeze sprang up, which soon crested the river with foam, and although it rendered the scene rather difficult for the photographers by reason of the waving of the banners and the movement of the various decorations, it was extremely refreshing, and contributed greatly to the pleasure of all concerned in the reception. Speaking of the photographers, we may mention that the gentlemen engaged by the reception commissioners have succeeded in producing very creditable views of the procession, both on large plates and in stereoscopic style. What we have said of the landing place, the wharves, and the public buildings, will apply equally to other divisions of the city; but if any particular points are deserving of special mention above others, it is the Citizens' canopy of arches, and the Sunday school children's platform in the domain. After the more immediate excitement of the royal progress was over the latter point became the centre of general attraction. On the procession crossing Park-street a somewhat lengthy stoppage occurred to enable the photographic artist stationed there to perform his duty. During this interval the city seemed to empty itself into the noble park, and the fences of the cricket ground, the rising ground behind the platform, and every available point of view were rushed by eager spectators. At a rough computation wo should say that from at least 10,000 to 15,000 persons were here assembled, and the scene was a brilliant and imposing one. The children's platform extended in the form of an amphitheatre for a distance of about 150 yards, and the seats ranged five deep, while hundreds of children who were unable to obtain accommodation lined the rear. The children were for the most part dressed uniformly, the girls wearing white dresses and blue sashes, and the boys sailor hats and blue favors. A vast number of small Union Jacks were distributed among the schools, and the waving of those added materially to the general effect. The various scenes in connection with the reception will, however, be described in detail below......
......
In the above order the procession moved away under the emblematic arch, amid the cheers of the populace. This arch was a most appropriate and imposing structure. The piers were composed wholly of oil barrels, and, illustrative of our whaling trade, had a fine effect, and the top, piled up in the form of a high pyramid, with samples of our porter, ale, beer, jams, leather, wheat, barley, oats, &c., &c, and surmounted by the huge jaws of a whale, the merchant ensign of Britain floating over all, formed a most characteristic trompe l'oeil. Beneath this, on the river side of the arch, was the inscription, "Welcome Sailor Prince," and on the other side, " Welcome to Tasmania." The feature which would, we imagine, most please His Royal Highness in connection with this structure, would be the two fine whale boats which surmounted the side arches, and which were manned by crews of six native youths attired in red shirts and sailor hats. These lads peaked their oars and cheered as the Prince's carriage passed under the archway. All the stands along the route of the procession at this point were densely crowded, and the enthusiasm of the spectators knew no bounds. The principal stands were at Belbin and Dowdell's at the Old Market, and at the lower end of Murray-street, and the occupants of each cheered, waved their handkerchiefs, or threw bouquets as the pro-cession passed. Gradually it wended its way up Murray-street towards the first of the Government arches, where the word "Welcome," in roses again, greeted the Prince, and his carriage passed under the arch....

Presently the swell of voices which prelude the march of an approaching crowd grew more and more audible, and in about a quarter of-an hour from the moment of His Royal Highness putting his foot on the landing stage, the head of the procession showed beneath the archway abutting on the government offices. Tim array passed on in the order in which it had been marshalled, as already described, on the wharf until the carriage of His Royal Highness had arrived opposite the parliamentary platform, when a halt was called in order to allow of the National Anthem being sung, as arranged in the programme, by the ladies assembled in front of the government buildings, aided by the occupants of the platform on the opposite side of the street. The anthem was sung with commendable precision, but the volume of sound was not sufficient to render it as effective as could have been desired. At this point a photographic picture was taken by Mr. Stewart, who was stationed for the purpose in one of the windows of the tower of St. David's Cathedral. The stay was of brief duration, but during its continuance there was some good humored crowding around the Prince's carriage, induced by a loyal curiosity to see His Royal Highness in as immediate proximity as possible; but the pressure arising from this cause rapidly subsided on the procession resuming its march. The progress along Murray and Liverpool streets was not marked by any event worthy of special mention, and the flag decorations, though profuse, were of necessity to such an extent repetitions of those previously described, as to render it needless to attempt describing them in detail..
.
THE CITIZENS' ARCH.
This is a structure worthy of the citizens,-a noble arch,-an elegant arch,-built by the Government as far as the woodwork is concerned, but the decorations were supplied by the citizens at a cost of from £120 to £130. And they are worthy of the occasion. A quadruple arch, rising to a height of 57 feet, and surmounted by a floral crown, 10 foot in height, with a cross of 2 feet, completes a structure worthy of the advent of an emperor. But in addition to this, the arch is profusely decorated with evergreens and flowers. On the front facing Liverpool-street, in the west, is the inscription, "The Citizens greet you," surmounted by two Union Jacks, partly folded, and from the centres of the four arches were suspended baskets of flowers. The arches rest on four pilasters, forming a pediment, and entwined with native shrubs and creepers, the base being formed by fern fronds from the Huon track, and kept fresh and fragrant by constant jets of fresh water. The arch was designed by Mr. C. Walch, and for the information of our country friends, we may describe it briefly as a quadruple arch, the four corners springing from Mr. Graham's to Messrs. Russells', and from Messrs. Walch's to Messrs. Saliers.' We may add here that a contretemps occurred during the progress of the procession at this part by a woman falling down, and being trampled on, but, fortunately, no serious injury was sustained. In fact, the police, aided by the special constables, maintained the most complete order and regularity. At the corner of Elizabeth and Liverpool-streets the scene was particularly gay and striking. Flags and banners were flaunting from many houses, and at Messrs. Walch's a rather novel but pleasing effect was produced by the display of flags at the windows, the staffs of which were entwined with wreaths of roses. At Messrs. Salier's wreaths of overgreens were carried in front of the house, which had a very pretty appearance. At Messrs' R.D. and W. Russell's the building was covered with flowers and evergreens, and Messrs. Harcourt, Holmes, G. Johnson, and Hinsby displayed similar floral decorations. Proceeding towards the domain the same decorations of flags and evergreens met the eye in every direction, until it rested on the arch erected by the hospital, when it received rather an unpleasant check, as the arch in question was more like the entrance to a cemetery, than an object of welcome and gratulation to a Royal Prince Passing this by, however, the procession moved onwards, and on arriving in view of the domain a scene of surpassing bounty and interest met the view. There, ranged in seats provided for them, were seen some hundreds, nay, thousands of children, belonging to the various Sunday-schools, and who were waiting to greet our royal visitor with an "Ode of Welcome," A more gratifying spectacle than this we never beheld, although in olden times wo have witnessed the annual gatherings of the charity children in St. Paul's, London. When the carriage with His Royal Highness and the Governor came in view of the domain a stoppage took place, and we observed that His Royal Highness, as he looked towards the children, seemed very highly pleased with so novel and so interesting a spectacle. No doubt, indeed, but that our sailor Prince was much delighted, for he could have witnessed nothing of the kind,-so largely carried out, at least,-in any of the neighboring colonies. We may add that the windows of the houses en route were filled with spectators, and several stands on the line of the procession were fairly occupied....
Source: THE DUKE OF EDINBURGH IN TASMANIA. (1868, January 8). The Mercury p. 2.
Link: https://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article8849902

The Tasmanian Times Special Edition ran a lengthy report on each stage of the Duke's tour around Hobart. Thomas Nevin's colleague Samuel Clifford produced a fine series of stereoscopic and album prints of the day, which he advertised for sale on the 26th February 1868.



TRANSCRIPT
PHOTOGRAPHS CONNECTED WITH H.R.H. THE.DUKE OF EDINBURGH'S VISIT TO TASMANIA.
Landing in State, "instantaneous," stereoscopic and album.
The Landing, 10 x 8.
The Galatea, 10 x 8, stereoscopic and album.
Emblematic Arch, 10 x 8, stereoscopic and album.
State Carriage, with Outriders und Orderlies, cabinet!
The Duke's Saddle Horse, album.
H. R. H. His Excellency, and Company at Government House', 10 x 8.
S. CLIFFORD, Liverpool-street, Prize Medallist [sic] at Melbourne, and highest Award at New Zealand.
Advertising (1868, February 26). The Mercury (Hobart, Tas. : 1860 - 1954), p. 1.
Link: http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article8850754

Citizens Arch 1868 Duke's visit, S. Clifford photo

Emblematic Arch, 10 x 8, stereoscopic and album.
Photographer Samuel Clifford 1868
Archives Office of Tasmania Ref: PH30-1-31



TRANSCRIPT
THE EMBLEMATIC ARCH.
In this order the procession moved away under the Emblematic Arch, erected by the Citizens' Reception Committee. This was declared on all sides to be a novel and striking feature in the various symbols of welcome offered to the Prince, and very successfully carried out. The piers were built up of tun butts, used in our whaling trade. The arch itself being composed of a main and two smaller arches, surmounted by bales of wool, pockets of hops, cases of preserves, bundles of shingles, leather, and bark used in tanning, sheaves of wheat, and a variety of the other products of the colony. Above the whole the jaw bones of a sperm whale. The side openings were crowned by two whale boats manned by the proper number of hands dressed in whaling costume. The whole of the arch was embellished with our beautiful ferns and flowers. On the side to meet the Prince's view was the legend " Welcome to Tasmania," and on the other side was "Welcome Sailor Prince." The top of it was decorated with flags. The whole line of the procession from the landing stage was also decorated with flags. Every halting place or stoppage was taken advantage of to loudly cheer our Royal visitor, who courteously responded to the same by bowing. Along the wharf and up Murray-street were several commodious stands tastefully decorated, and filled with well dressed people who all cheered lustily as the Prince passed. The procession moved slowly upwards from the wharf amidst continuous cheering, between two lines of Military who kept the route clear from the landing stage to the arch in Murray street.
THE STATE LANDING. (1868, February 1). The Tasmanian Times (Hobart Town, Tas. : 1867 - 1870), p. 3.
Link: http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article232857843

8 January 1868: FIRE on the "KANGAROO"
The Twins steamer ferry Kangaroo built by Elizabeth Rachel (Day) Nevin's uncle Captain Edward Goldsmith in 1854-55, was sold to Askin Morrison in 1857, then to James Staines Taylor in 1864 who operated it for the next 40 years. Under his command on this day of celebrations with a full complement of passengers greeting the Prince's yacht Galatea, fireworks exploded over the deck, catching ladies' dresses on fire and causing them to faint.



TRANSCRIPT
THE TWINS STEAMER.
The ladies and gentlemen who were to take part in the torchlight aquatic procession began to assemble about half-past 7 o'clock, accompanied by their friends and a large number of ladies and gentlemen invited by the committee. The evening was beautifully fine. The sea breeze which had been blowing briskly all day, died away, aud gave place to a westerly wind. The moon shone beautifully, and rode through an almost cloudless sky. The temperature was sufficiently cool to render shawls and wrappers a comfortable addition to the ordinary dress. There were on board altogether about six hundred ladies and gentlemen, including many of the leading inhabitants of the city. The entire management of the procession was under the direction of J. Davies, Esq.,M.H. A., who was assisted by H.S. Barrett, Esq., M.H. A., and the arrangements to give effect to the demonstration were as perfect as they possibly could be. The whole of the living freight being on board, the band, under the leadership of Mr. Thomas, struck up a quickstep march, the red fire was lighted, and a signal rocket fired. The steamer got slowly under way, and proceeded towards the Galatea, amid cheers from the shore. A little delay was caused in arranging the flotilla, during which the rockets and red and green fires were occasionally burnt, and the band played some of its most inspiring strains. The steamer went slowly round the Galatea, the company singing Rule Britannia with great precision and effect. The scene at this time was brilliant and beautiful in the extreme. The long line of boats, with lighted torches undulating with the waves, and slowly advancing was one of the prettiest sights ever witnessed on the banks of the Derwent. Three hearty cheers were given as the steamer passed the Galatea, which were returned by the men on board the frigate, the band at the same time striking up a lively air. Green fires were now burnt and several rockets thrown up, the band playing a march, and then the company sang " O'er the calm and sparkling waters," which sounded very beautifully, the voices blending well. As soon as this ended the Galatea exhibited a blue fire at each port hole, and one from the jibboom end. The effect was magnificent, and there was but one feeling of delight at this brilliant exhibition. The flotilla now steamed gently towards Government House, firing rockets and burning alternatively red and green fires, the company singing "Lo, the gladsome day is breaking," and with increasing effort and precision, as the amateurs seemed to gain confidence. Everything was proceeding as " merry as a marriage bell," and all on board were enjoying themselves thoroughly, and were in the greatest state of enthusiasm and delight, when one of those accidents which seem to mock all human prudence and foresight occurred. A large case of rockets had been placed at the opposite end of the steamer to where the orchestra was situated, and it was believed quite sufficiently secured from accident. The man in charge went to fire a serpent, and the sparks fell in among the rockets, and set them on fire. In an instant a scene of great confusion occurred. Several of the rockets flew about the deck and exploded, and the greatest danger was for a few minutes apprehended. A rush was made to the other end of the steamer, and several ladies fainted, and the clothes of one or two caught fire, but were quickly extinguished by the bystanders. Several gentlemen at a great risk made a rush to the burning box of fireworks, and after getting in one or two instances burnt on the hands, the box was thrown overboard and all danger ceased. The deck of the steamer was burnt in several places, and the bulwarks were on fire, but a few buckets of water promptly extinguished all remnants of fire. The alarm among the ladies was very great, and it was some time before many of them could get over the fright which had been given them. Mr Davies and others were indefatigable in reassuring them, but every time afterwards that a rocket went off, or the green or red fires were burnt, their alarm was renewed. By the time order was restored the flotilla had reached its appointed place of Government House. The anchor was dropped, rockets fired, and the orchestra began in accordance with the arrangements to go through the programme again. " Rule Britannia" and the other pieces were gone through with great precision and effect, and the spirit stirring strains had a most invigorating effect on those whom the recent accident had rendered timid and nervous. The " Welcome to Prince Alfred" was especially well rendered, and called forth many encomiums. The "National Anthem" closed the musical portion of the serenade, and the steamer weighed anchor and returned to town. On passing the Galatea "Rule Britannia" was again played by the band, and the large freight was landed safe, in spite of an accident which threatened once to be serious. Had it not been for the unfortunate explosion the serenade would, as it still must be considered, have been the most beautiful and successful spectacle ever witnessed in the colonies. On landing at the wharf three hearty cheers were given for Mr. Davies, for the energetic and successful way in which all the arrangements had been carried out.
Source: THE DUKE OF EDINBURGH IN TASMANIA. 1868, January 8. The Mercury p. 3.
Link: https://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article8849902

Torchlight procession 1868 Hobart

Title Aquatic torchlight procession, Hobart Town. [picture]
Contributor(s) Gill, S. T., 1818-1880 artist.
Publisher Melbourne : Robert Stewart
Date February 29, 1868.
Description print : wood engraving.
Notes Wood engraving published in The illustrated Melbourne Post.
State Library of Victoria
Link: https://handle.slv.vic.gov.au/10381/47696

10 January 1868: FORTY POUNDS in debt
On January 10, Charles E. Walch wrote a letter addressed to both the editor of the Tasmanian Times and the Hobart Mercury, requesting their readers to meet a shortfall of forty pounds - £40 - in subscription funds to complete the decorations on the Citizens' Arch.
THE CITIZENS ARCH.
To the Editor of the Tasmanian Times
SIR,—The Committee of The Citizens' Arch, desire to avail themselves of' your columns, that it may be generally known that a sum of about Fifty Pounds is still required to pay for the decorations in addition to the seventy pounds subscribed by the Committee and others. The Citizens of Hobart Town may well feel proud of their Arch, for it far surpasses any yet erected by their wealthier neighbour, but that their boasting may be justified, they must clear off the debt of forty pounds, and in order to accomplish this, Mr. Jas. E. Salier, Mr. W. Weaver, and myself are prepared to receive any donations. no matter how small, and I need not add, how large.
I am, Sir,
Yours obediently,
CHAS. E. WALCH,
Secretary and Treasurer.
Source: THE CITIZENS ARCH. (1868, January 10). The Tasmanian Times p. 3.
Link: https://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article232857259

THE CITIZENS' ARCH.
To the Editor of the Mercury .
Dear Sir - Having practically shown your own interest in the Citizens' Arch, I trust that you will still further aid the committee by inserting this letter in the columns of your paper, its purport simply to inform the citizens of Hobart Town other friends that a sum of about forty pounds is still required to defray the expenses of decoration their arch. The cost of the decorations will amount to about £110; of this sum the committees have subscribed among themselves 12s in cash, (I won't say one word about the value of the personal services of some of their number), and have received other subscriptions bringing the total up to £70. In undertaking the responsibility of decorating this arch which I am fully justified in styling the finest, both in design and decoration, yet erected in the Australian colonies - the committee felt confident that their fellow-citizens would stand by them, and now that the arch speaks for itself and funds are required, the committee would not cast such a slur on them as to make any appeal, but would simply state that three members of the committee, Messrs. Weaver, James E. Salier, and Charles E. Walch, are prepared to receive any donation, however small, towards meeting the deficit of forty pounds.
I am, dear Sir,
Yours faithfully
CHAS. E. WALCH,
Secretary and Treasurer.
Source: THE CITIZEN' ARCH. (1868, January 10). The Mercury , p. 2.
Link: https://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article8849936

Photograph Albums presented to the Prince
Thomas J. Nevin was one of a dozen or so local photographers invited by the Reception Commissioners to submit prints for inclusion in two albums to be presented to Prince Alfred on his departure from Hobart. His contributions to the album of Tasmanian scenery would have included his photographs of the Citizens' Arch in Liverpool Street, his studio and residence in Elizabeth Street seen from corner of Patrick Street, the Orphan School at New Town, and several houses at Kangaroo Valley including the house his father built there. His contributions to the album of children's portraits, some lightly hand-coloured, would have included his portrait of younger brother Jack (William John) Nevin (see below).



Source: Tasmanian Times (Hobart Town, Tas. : 1867 - 1870), Monday 20 January 1868, page 2

TRANSCRIPT
PHOTOGRAPHIC ALBUM PRESENTED TO HIS ROYAL HIGHNESS.
On Saturday the album of photographs of Tasmanian scenery which has been prepared by the Prince Alfred preparation committee "for H.R.H, the Duke of Edinburgh from the colonists as memorial of his visit to Tasmania in H.SCS. Galatea," was presented on board that vessel to Hie Royal Highness by the chairman of the committee, the Hon. James Milne Wilson, mayor of the city, accompanied by Mr. Hugh M. Hull, Secretary to the committee. There were present also the Hon. Sir R. Dry, the Hon. T. D. Chapman, the Hon. W. L. Dobson, and Capt. Tarleton. Mr. Wilson accompanied the presentation with few remarks, and H.R.H. expressed the pleasure he felt in receiving so beautiful a present, saying that there many parts of the colony he would have wished very much to see, and that he hoped to enjoy a leisure hour in looking over the album. The gentlemen named had then the honor of lunching in the Prince's dining cabin. Besides H.R.H.'s staff and Lord Newry, His Excellency the Governor, and Mrs. and Miss Gore Browne were present. The album which was admitted to be the most costly book ever prepared in the colony, and valuable as illustrating our lovely scenery, and our beautiful children, (of whom 8,000 welcomed H.R.H. in the two towns alone) is of imperial size, bound in crimson morocco, gilt and ornamented in an elaborate and tasteful manner. It contains 83 photographs of Ferntree vallies, river scenery, public buildings, schools, hospitals, orphan asylums, country towns, such as Richmond, Deloraine, New Norfolk, Pontville, Circular Head, Swansea, - views of several private residences, such as Mona Yale, Sunnyside, Cascades, Dr. Officer's and Mr. Sharland's, and of Government House, and the R.S. Gardens. There are also 48 coloured portraits of our most beautiful children, selected from the studies of the photographic artists who go in for that line. The committee also succeeded in placing in the album the following plates in immediate connexion with the Prince's visit to the colony:-
1. The Galatea as she lay in harbour.
2. The Landing in State.
3. The Emblematic Arch.
4. The Public Buildings' Arch.
5. The Savings Bank decorated, and the Ladies' Platform.
6. The Citizens' Arch.
7. The Children in the Domain.
8. The Laying of the Cathedral Stone.
9. The O'Briens' Bridge Arch.
The title page was drawn by Mr. Alfred Randall in letters of gold, surrounded by wreaths of Macquarie Harbour pine trailed on twigs, and in each corner of the page was an inimitable sketch in pen and ink by Mr. W. C. Piguenit, the subjects being Risdon, Prince of Wales' Bay, Benlomond, and the. rocks at New Norfolk respectively. The Pictures were accompanied by an elaborate index in gold letters by Mr. Randall.

His Royal Highness was pleased to request Mr. Hull to procure for him duplicate copies of all the pictures in the album, for the purpose of aiding in illustrating a work which His Royal Highness is preparing in connection with his visit to the Australian Colonies.
Source: PHOTOGRAPHIC ALBUM PRESENTED. TO HIS ROYAL HIGHNESS.
Tasmanian Times (Hobart Town, Tas. : 1867 - 1870), Monday 20 January 1868, page 2
https://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article232857474

Thomas Nevin and partner Robert Smith, operating as the firm Nevin & Smith, were indeed "photographers who go in for that line" of photographing children and colouring their portraits as contributions to the promised album for the Prince. Toddlers to teens sat for them, including young Jack Nevin (William John, later Constable John Nevin), Thomas Nevin's younger brother who posed for this full-length portrait during the Prince's visit in 1868. The typical pose and dress of young Jack Nevin, choices made whenever he was photographed while still a youth, were with left arm bent, hand on hip, clean shaven (until his twenties when he favoured a moustache), a three piece suit with fob chain, and jacket with velvet revers (lapels). The little bowler was brand new, placed next to two decorative pot plants. The decor in the studio at this time - January 1868 - featured the heavy plinth with plaster panels inset with a wreath which Thomas Nevin acquired from Alfred Bock's auction and which appears in one of his photos of the Bayles sisters. The large lozenge patterned carpet softened with white edges and floral centre appears in several of these Nevin & Smith portraits.



Subject: William John Nevin (1852-1891), known as Jack to the family;
also known as Constable John Nevin from 1870-1891
Photographers: Thomas J. Nevin (older brother) and Robert Smith, as the firm NEVIN & SMITH
Location and Date: 140 Elizabeth St. Hobart, Tasmania, January 1868.
Details: verso stamped with Prince of Wales blazon of three feathers, coronet and Ich Dien;
"From Nevin & Smith late Bock's, 140 Elizabeth St. Hobart Town"
Source: Private Collection, Sydney Rare Books Auction, June 2019

1901: Resurrect the Citizen's Arch?

22 January 1891: F. J. PATERSON
The stereograph of the Citizens' Arch attributed to F. J. Paterson bears no studio mark or inscription to warrant accreditation, even if it was produced in 1868 as an original, possibly taken by him at the exact same spot where Thomas J. Nevin stood to take the first one, though that would seem an unlikely occurrence.  F. J. Paterson was certainly active as a photographer in the 1890s, according to the report of an exhibition held in 1891, whereas photographs by him taken in the 1860s are rare, if extant at all, and only known as part of the Cox family collections.

This article mentions F. J. Paterson's work in some detail. Note the patronising tone towards the photographic work of the women who contributed to an exhibition held at Temperance Hall, 21 January 1891:

PHOTOGRAPHIC AND ART ASSOCIATION
There were those who, when the Tasmanian Photographic and Art Association was founded some four years ago, did not hesitate to characterise the movements an amateur's fad, and a mushroom growth that would, they prophesied, die as rapidly as it had sprung into existence. Time, however, has proved that the photographic art, apart from that particular portion of it which has to do with those who gain their living by its practice, has not only come amongst us, but has come to stay. The ranks of our amateur photographers are daily swelling, and as each successive exhibition of their handiwork has come around there has been placed on evidence that they are not more spoilers of plates and paper, but workers imbued with the enthusiasm of art and the determination to excel. Indeed, they trim their professional brothers very close, and in some instances the eye of the expert is requisite to detect and define a tints of comparison. The exhibition opened yesterday in the Temperance Hall, is the largest collection of photographs yet shown. These have been grouped around the room together with paintings and collections of material and instruments used in photography. Of the exhibits made by amateurs, those of Mr. Aikenhead, of West Devonport, stand head and shoulders above the rest. They mc nil silver prints, but the artist has shown excellent taste in choice of subjects (all landscape and the lighting is most perfect. Mr. Aikenhead is the holder of the senior prize for the current year. Mr Gruncell is a new man, but has succeeded in turning out some very creditable work, and Mr. F. J. Paterson maintains the reputation he has gained for his excellence in relation to instantaneous work, his pictures of steamers and yachts being perfect specimens of this class of work. Sir. N. Oldham has not had time at his disposal to furnish other than an ordinary exhibit, but his choice of subjects has been good. Mr. Shepherd's animal portraiture furnishes so me most amusing pictures, Miss Frean's views are well selected, although, of course, the the ladies are always handicapped in this work. Mr. R. Downing has effectively copied some old engravings, and Mr A. Butler, whose specialty appears to be instantaneous, water pictures, is to be complimented on, his id suits. Miss Dickson has secured good negatives, but the work of vignetting has been but poorly done. The exhibits by professionals comprise portraits by both Messrs. Watson and Co., and Messrs. Wherrett Bros., and that of the former show considerable recent improvement. Mr. J. Anson contributes a fine group of landscapes. Captain Forrest heads the list of exhibitors of oil paintings with a fine picture of the gully at the back of the Cascades. The lighting is effective, and the warmth of tone noticeable in this artist's paintings of Tasmanian scenery is well preserved. A second contribution (unfinished) is a derelict barque, an excellent piece of sea painting. Mr. E. Mace, jnr , has been on the West Coast, and his pictures of the Pieman River Mount Zeehan, are interesting. "In the Lake Country" is not so satisfactory a piece of work. Miss Hope's picture of Tasmanian berries is on exhibition although not a new painting by this lady Mrs. Reichenburg has conveyed considerable force into her picture "In the Engadine Valley," although, occasional weekly classes in foliage work are perceptible. Miss Dickson's little piece of mountain scenery is charming. Other contributors were Misses Carraway, M. Williams, and Elliott. A collection of Fijian curios is loaned. by Mrs. Lang, of Risdon, A collection of fine bromide, enlargement is also worthy of special mention. In a separate room the president (Mr. Curzon Allport) exhibited a collection of pictures, many of which are known as works of art. Proceedings opened at 11 o'clock, following the arrival of His Excellency the Governor, who is patron of the Association, take along a good attendance, In the evening there was a good attendance and the progressive provided for the entertainment of patrons give general satisfaction. It embraced a short address by the President of The Association and its work, which proved interesting alike to members and those not, within the past, A short experimental lecture by Mr. Paterson on "The production of the photographic picture " also formed an interesting loin, but chiefly successful was the splendid lime-light, exhibition with some of the features of which the Hobart public are already convey any, but which loses none of its attractive-ness by repetition. The entire arrangements reflected great credit on the Executive Copies notice, the secretary (Mr. Nat Oldham), and assistant secretary (Mr. F. J. Patterson). The exhibition will be open this evening, when, in addition to the lime-light pictures already spoken of, other attractions will be presented in the form of the lime-light exhibition with the Mining lanterns and oxy-hydrogen microscope, thrill particulars, I can be cleaned from the announcement published elsewhere.

Source: PHOTOGRAPHIC AND ART ASSOCIATION. (1891, January 22). The Mercury p. 3.
Link: https://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article12711860

2 April 1901: PROPOSAL to erect the Citizen's Arch again for another Royal visit
Designer and decorator of the Citizen's Arch for the 1868 Royal visit, Charles E. Walch requested that the Mercury reprint a paragraph about the arch first published on January 8, 1868, by way of suggesting the arch could be resurrected for the forthcoming Royal Visit of the Duke and Duchess of York in 1901:

TRANSCRIPTS
THE VISIT OF THE DUKE AND DUCHESS OF YORK.
Sir,-As it appears that the Government, as far as I know, has not decided on the exact form the public welcome to the Duke and Duchess of York is to take, permit me to suggest that what was done in one instance a generation since, on the occasion of the visit of the Duke of Edinburgh, might well form part of our welcome on this new occasion. I allude to the Citizens' Arch, which was erected at the junction of Elizabeth and Liverpool streets. I enclose an extract from "The Mercury" of January 8, 1868, giving a descriptive account of the arch, which, I think, will be read with interest -
Yours, etc.,
CHAS. E. WALCH.
THE CITIZENS' ARCH.
This is a structure worthy of the citizen and a noble arch and elegant arch built by the Government as far as the woodwork is concerned, but the decorations were supplied by the citizens at a cost of from £120 to £200, and they are worthy of the occasion. A quadruple arch, rising to a height of 57ft., and surmounted by a floral crown, 10ft. in height, with a cross of 2ft., completes a structure worthy of the advent of an Emperor. But in addition to this, the arch is profusely decorated with evergreens and flowers. On the front facing Liverpool-street, on the west, is the inscription, "The Citizens Greet You," surmounted by two Union Jacks, partly folded, and from the centre of the four arches are suspended baskets of flowers. The arches rest on four pilasters forming a pediment, and entwined with native shrubs and creepers, the base being formed with fern fronds from the Huon track, and kept fresh and fragrant by constant jets of fresh water. The arch was designed by Mr. C. Walch, and for the information of our country friends, we may describe it briefly as a quadruple arch, the four corners springing from Mr. Graham's to Messrs. Russell's, and from Messrs. Walch's to Messrs. Salier's.
Source: Mercury (Hobart, Tas. : 1860 - 1954), Tuesday 2 April 1901, page 3
Reprinted from THE DUKE OF EDINBURGH. (1867, December 24). The Mercury p. 3.
Link: https://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article8849641

Citizens Arch, Hobart 1901

Photograph - 'Citizens Arch,' Macquarie Street, to celebrate the visit of Their Royal Highnesses The Duke and Duchess of Cornwall and York
Item Number: NS5742/1/38
Start Date: 02 Jul 1901
End Date: 06 Jul 1901
Format: photograph
Creating Agency: Edward Swarbreck Hall and Family (NG308)
Series: Photographs (NS5742) 01 Jan 1870 31 Mar 1933
View online:https://libraries.tas.gov.au/Record/Archives/NS5742-1-38

Addenda:

1.TRANSPARENCY of the Prince, Lands Dept



Source: THE CARNIVAL WEEK. (1868, January 24). The Mercury p. 2.
Link: https://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article8850166

TRANSCRIPT
THE LATE ILLUMINATION-.-The following should have been added to the Davey-street list of transparencies noticed on the night of the illumination ¡-- Captain Bateman, angle of Davey street and Molle-streets-Crown and anchor transparencies with the words, " Alfred may your voyage through life be prosperous." In the second window a crown and star, with the words " Welcome England's Sailor Prince ;" the fan-light being also adorned with a colored transparency. Mrs. Garrett's house in Davey-street was tastefully adorned with transparencies in the whole of the front windows. In the upper centre window was an anchor with the letter "A" also ; in the windows right and left, the whole being surmounted by stars. The lower windows were decorated with transparencies of the Union Jack, and the flag red, white, and blue, and in the fanlight was placed an illuminated transparency of Prince Alfred. Mr. Fielding Browne's house was illuminated throughout, with colored transparencies in each window ; and the front and end windows of Mr. A. Gellie's residence, also in Davey-street, were brightly illuminated with candles.



TRANSCRIPT
0:19 Hi. I'm Elspeth Wishart, I'm the senior curator of cultural heritage at the
0:23 Tasmanian Museum and Art Gallery and I'd like to talk to you about this
0:27 fascinating object. A large banner which has been a mystery to us
0:36 and I think that's really what excites me about it. It was brought into the
0:41 museum 30 years ago from a government department, the Lands Department, and we
0:48 didn't really know much about it except that it had been connected with a royal
0:53 visit in the eighteen hundreds. So we wrapped it up, catalogued it and put
0:59 it away and then we did this exhibition, The Changing Landscapes Creating
1:04 Tasmania, and we were looking for objects that was helping Tasmanians to find
1:13 their identity in the 1800s, so I remembered that we had this object so we
1:18 got it out and because we didn't have much information about it we took a
1:23 couple of avenues. We started doing research on it and then we also looked
1:30 at it physically to see what clues it could give us and that was really where
1:34 we started to get excited because we thought it was a large painting that was
1:38 perhaps framed and hung in some important place but when you look at the
1:42 close details it's very naive, it's got very light
1:48 paint on it and it's got paint on both sides but then we looked at the edges
1:54 and we found that it had been put on a stretcher but it had never been framed
2:00 so we started to think, what what was this object? It was maybe a prop for a
2:06 play or some sort of just temporary ephemeral thing – it doesn't have an
2:13 artist signature or anything on it. And then it was suggested by one of our
2:19 curators that maybe it was a transparency. Now in the 1800s
2:24 transparencies were used for festivals, they were usually lit from behind which
2:30 would make sense with the light paint and they were used for
2:35 special occasions, so we started to read up about this and looking at the royal
2:40 visits and we found that in 1868 the first ever royal visit came to Australia
2:47 and that was of Prince Alfred who was the Duke of Edinburgh, he was the second
2:52 son of Queen Victoria, and we were able to identify that this is actually an
2:59 image of Prince Alfred. And the details show him surrounded with the Union
3:07 Jacks and ash trees and acorns and oak trees and he's leaning on a maritime
3:20 object and he's got anchors and then of course there's this ribbon saying
3:25 "Welcome to Tasmania". So it all sort of began to fall into place and then we
3:30 found a newspaper account of his visits around the world and everywhere he went
3:36 there were massive illuminations where people had light displays and
3:43 transparencies such as this in their windows, you know, from small little paned
3:49 windows to large windows and when we were reading the account in the Mercury
3:54 in January in 1868 there was a description of this exact transparency
4:04 being displayed in the Lands Department, which is where this came from, or the
4:10 Survey Department, which is now, which is still in Davey Street, the old St Mary's
4:15 Hospital, and it was painted by one of the draftsman from the Survey
4:20 Department – Stan Dunnett  [sic - Frank Dunnett 1822-1891]. So all that information was already there and we
4:25 were able to piece it together so suddenly this sort of rather faded, worn
4:32 banner became a really significant piece of Tasmania's history and to this date
4:39 we think it's the only one in the world remaining from
4:43 the whole of his, the prince's, global tour to many many countries. So we're very
4:51 excited to have this and would like to put it out there if anyone knows of any
4:55 other ones we'd be really interested to hear about it.
English (auto-generated)

Source: Tasmanian Museum and Art Gallery YouTube Channel
Link: https://youtu.be/KR4E0vvnJP8?feature=shared

2. BIOGRAPHY of Charles Edward WALCH (1830–1915)
ADB: https://adb.anu.edu.au/biography/walch-charles-edward-4783



Walch's Corner, Elizabeth Street and Liverpool Street [unattributed]
Publication Information: [Tasmania : s.n., between 1860 and 1870].
Physical description: 1 photographic print : b&w ; 150 x 201 mm.
Citation: Digitised item from: Allport Library and Museum of Fine Arts, State Library of Tasmania.
Link: https://libraries.tas.gov.au/Record/Library/SD_ILS-684701

RELATED POSTS main weblog

Prisoner Charles J. GARFORTH said he would make Superintendent Adolarious H. BOYD pay dearly, 1875

C. J. GARFORTH, constable, musician, husband and prisoner
A. H. BOYD, prison officer Port Arthur penal establishment
Mary Ann LARKIN, bounty emigrant: marriage and children

The photograph of Charles Garforth by T. J. Nevin 1875



Recto image and numbers:
Prisoner Charles Garforth, the name also spelt as Garfitt and Garfoot per M S Elphinstone 2, 1848.
Photographed by government contractor Thomas J. Nevin at the Hobart Gaol before the trial while the prisoner was under remand, January 1875.

This carte-de-visite was acquired by the QVMAG in the 1930s from the estate of collector John Watt Beattie who salvaged 300 or so mugshots taken for police by T. J. Nevin, 1870s, from police records, criminal rap sheets and photo books.The number "174" was inscribed on the mount below the image when listed as part of Beattie's collection at the QVMAG in the 1970s-1980s. It was not one of the 50 or so mugshots removed from Beattie's collection in 1983 which were exhibited at the Port Arthur Heritage Site and returned to the TMAG in Hobart instead of being returned to Beattie's 1900's original collection in Launceston.

Verso cdv Charles Garforth

Verso inscriptions:
Top left: QVM: 1985: P: 0111 (black and white copy reproduced from sepia cdv at the QVMAG in 1985)
Sideways on right: 18..? : 78: 22 (very faint date archived at QVMAG )
Sideways on right: QVM FILE NO. 147 | 283 over 7 (in stamp box listed in 1970s for exhibition)
In centre, and below: inscription dates from 1900s by Beattie et al for sale and display:
"283 / Charles Garfitt/Garfoot/Garforth per M. S. Elphinstone 2 (1848)
Taken at Port Arthur 1874
"
Source: Queen Victoria Museum and Art Gallery, Launceston, Tasmania
Link: https://collection.qvmag.tas.gov.au/fmi/webd/QVMAGweb

Charles Garforth's history with A. H. Boyd
The Hobart Town Advertiser on Saturday 28 June 1862, page 2 reported that the Municipal Council had received a letter from Mr. Boyd announcing that John Garforth had been appointed a constable. But just two months later, in August 1862, Adolarious Humphrey Boyd was advising the Mayor's Court to fine Charles Garforth for being drunk on duty, and recommended his discharge from the constabulary.

1862: Boyd v. Garforth



Mercury (Hobart, Tas. : 1860 - 1954), Friday 8 August 1862, page 8

TRANSCRIPT
MAYOR'S COURT.
THURSDAY, AUGUST 7TH. BEFORE the Right Worshipful the Mayor and Mr. Alderman Risby.
BOYD V. GARFORTH.
This was an information against Charles John Garforth, a constable of the City Police, charging him with misconduct in being drunk on his beat, on the 3rd instant.
The defendant, a respectable looking young man, pleaded guilty, when Acting-Serjeant Vaughan explained the particulars of the case.
The Mayor said that he regretted to see so respectable a young man in his present position. He had only been recently received into the force, and ought to have behaved better. However, His Worship had only one duty to perform, as the regulations were strict and peremptory.
The defendant was fined 10s., with a recommendation to be dismissed from the force.
Source: Mercury (Hobart, Tas. : 1860 - 1954), Friday 8 August 1862, page 8
Link: https://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article8809470

1870: clerk at Port Arthur penal establishment
Despite A. H. Boyd's call for Garforth's dismissal from the constabulary in 1862, he must have acquitted himself well in Boyd's estimation to have gained employment as a clerk in the Port Arthur penal administration by 1870. Garforth's musical ability on the piano ensured his attendance at important functions presided over by A. H. Boyd, suggesting a relationship at a personal level had developed which would account for Garforth's bitter reaction to Boyd's loss of trust in him at trial in 1875 when he accused Garforth of embezzlement.



Page119: Colonial Penal Establishment, Port Arthur
Clerk, C. J. Garforth,, Walch's Tasmanian Almanac
Created/Published Hobart, Tas. : J. Walch & Sons, 1870-[1971]
National Library of Australia, (1870).
Link: https://nla.gov.au/nla.obj-2898240000

1871: Charles Garforth plays the piano at official event

TRANSCRIPT
PRESENTATION at PORT ARTHUR-The officers of the penal establishment Port Arthur, assembled on Tuesday evening last, the 12th instant, at the public reading room, for the purpose of presenting an address and testimonial to Mr James Lawson, head keeper of the Insane Depot, previous to his retirement from office. The pleasing ceremony was preceded by some music, Mr Garforth presiding at the piano. The Civil Commandant, A. H. Boyd, Esq., lead the address, which he prefaced by expressing the gratification he felt in being able to bear public testimony to the excellence of Mr Lawson's character, and further stated that he really believed he had never met with a more upright and conscientious officer in the whole course of his experience - an eulogium which all present felt to be as well merited as it was graceful and appropriate. The address and reply will be found in another column. The testimonial consisted of a handsome tea service, which will remind Mr. Lawson, when far away, of the many years he has spent in the care of the unfortunate, and of the esteem and friendship of those he leaves behind. Music and singing were continued till about 10 o'clock, the Rev. W. Fitzgerald, Mr. J. L. Hill, and others taking part, and a most agreeable and pleasant evening was spent. Mr. Boyd proposed the health of the guest of the evening, which was responded to most heartily, and briefly, but feelingly, acknowledged.



Source: THE MERCURY. (1871, December 16). p. 2.
Link: https://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article8868654

1875: Garforth threatens Boyd in court
Employed as a clerk at the Cascades prison for females, Charles Garforth was charged in the City Police Court with the theft of £10, a charge he claimed his employer, prison superintendent Adolarious Humphrey Boyd, had confected, for which Garforth swore he would make Boyd pay dearly.

TRANSCRIPT
CITY POLICE COURT.
Thursday, January 14th, 1875. Before the Police Magistrate. ...
STEALING MONEY.- Charles John Garforth was charged with stealing £10, monies belonging to the Queen.

D. C. M'Guire stated that the prisoner had been under remand for embezzlement, but that charge had been withdrawn, and one of petty larceny substituted.

The prisoner pleaded not guilty,

Adolarius Humphrey Boyd deposed that he was superintendent at the gaol for females at the Cascades. The prisoner was engaged at that establishment as under-gaoler and clerk. On the last day of last month, witness gave him £l to complete certain moneys which had to be paid into the Treasury. The prisoner had moneys in hand before that. Witness gave him distinct instructions to pay the money into the Treasury on that or the following day. The sum that prisoner had been entrusted with was in all about £10. On Monday, the 4th instant, the prisoner quitted the establishment without leave, and did not return until the following Saturday evening. In consequence of information received, witness broke open the private drawer in prisoner's room, in presence of the matron and Mr. Seagar; there was no money there, only the two empty money bags. On the morning following the prisoner's return he was given into custody. Witness did not see him. The cheque which witness gave prisoner was one that had been received from Dr. Turnley, and was for £1. It was the business of the prisoner to have paid the money at once into the Treasury, as he received it for no other purpose; he had no authority from witness to convert the money to his own use.

In reply to the prisoner, Mr. Boyd stated that he had heard the reason why the prisoner left the establishment, which he mentioned, but as it was only hearsay, it could not be received as evidence. Mr. Boyd said the prisoner had served under him at Port Arthur ; he never had cause to doubt his honesty; there, nor was he ever absent from duty. Never had cause to doubt prisoner at the Cascades prior to this.

George William Fletcher deposed he was clerk in the Treasury, and it was his duty to receive moneys paid in there for the revenue. Did not know the prisoner ; he did not at the end of last month pay any money to witness on account of the Cascades Establishment. The last money paid in on account of the Cascades was on the 30th December, when Mr. Service paid in £24 8s. 10d. If the prisoner had stated that he had paid money into the Treasury about that time, he had stated that which was not true.

Mr. Boyd was recalled, and said that the money paid in by Mr. Service had nothing whatever to do with the prisoner ; it was for the washing account. Mr. Service was the collector of that money, and paid it in monthly.

Elizabeth Turner deposed that she was the wife of John Turner,and resided with him at the Dennison Hotel, Macquarie-street. Knew the prisoner, and remembered him coming to their house on the 30th December. That was the first time he had been there. He asked witness to lend him some money, and witness let him have £8 10s. Prisoner did not say what he wanted the money for ; he promised to repay the amount by seven o'clock that same evening, and he came about eight and repaid the money. It was in notes, gold, silver, and a cheque for £1. Did not have any conversation with prisoner about the cheque ; prisoner told witness it was Dr. Turnley's, but witness did not look at the signature. Witness afterwards paid the cheque to Mr. Biggins, collector for Mr. Walker, the brewer.

To the prisoner : The prisoner told witness he wanted the money because his wife was near her confinement, and be wanted to get some necessary articles. He told her that he could get the money. elsewhere, but he had not time to go to the wharf. The prisoner repaid witness four sovereigns, three £1 notes, a cheque for £1, and 10s. in silver, and said that he brought back the money untouched, except as to 20s. in silver, for which he had substituted a cheque for £1.

District Constable Bellany deposed that he apprehended the prisoner at the Cascade Factory on Sunday morning last. Told him that he was charged with embezzling money belonging to the Queen. The prisoner in reply, said it was quite a mistake ; he had paid the money into the treasury, and Mr. Midwood took it there. He further said that he would make Mr. Boyd pay dearly for this.

This was the case for the prosecution.

The prisoner, in defence, said that on the Monday he left his house from private motives, He could not say he left the establishment ; but from a domestic disagreement he had with his wife, in consequence of a letter sent to him by one of the female warders, he went away and returned on the Saturday evening. With respect to the cheque which Mrs. Turner spoke about, if he did wrong in paying it to her, he did it innocently. It was not his duty personally to pay money into the treasury ; it was usually sent down by a messenger. On the 30th ult., on the day the late Sheriff paid his last visit, he (the prisoner) was very busy, and put the money into an open box for the messenger to take, should he (the prisoner) be absent ; but he had so much to do that day that he never thought of looking to see if the messenger had taken it or not. The prisoner, called the following witnesses :-

Walter Scott deposed he was the messenger at the Cascades. Remembered the morning of the 30th ult., when the late Sheriff was there. Went to town about 1 o'clock, after getting some letters from prisoner, who took them out of the box. Returned about three o'clock, and went again to town between then and four o'clock, but did not find any letters in prisoner's box at that time. In the morning, prisoner gave witness all the letters that were in the box.

Thomas Todd deposed he was gatekeeper at the Cascades. Knew that every one had access to the office at the Cascades whether the clerk was there or not. Witness used to be in the office about six hours a day. There were two women employed about the offices to clean them out, and no one remained about the offices but those women while they were being cleaned out.

To the Bench: There was a desk in the office, which was kept by the prisoner under lock and key ; it was found locked after he left.

The Police Magistrate : In 1865 you were charged with a similar offence and committed for trial, receiving a sentence of four years' penal servitude, is that so ?

The prisoner : It is, your Worship, but since that time I have endeavoured by all means in my power to regain my character.

The Police Magistrate said the magistrates could have no doubt whatever as to their duty in this case. The evidence against the prisoner was so clear that any jury in the world would convict him upon it. The prisoner was entrusted with money for the special purpose of paying into the Treasury; but that money had not been paid into the Treasury, and had never been accounted for, and it was quite evident that the prisoner had converted the £1 cheque to his own use. It seemed impossible for the magistrates to do otherwise than convict the prisoner of the charge made against him. He was one of those clever men who seemed to be devoid of all principle, and when placed in positions of trust could not resist the temptation to convert money entrusted to him by fears for this was the second time he had done it. If the magistrates had chosen to commit the prisoner to the Supreme Court he would have received a heavier sentence than it was in their power to impose. As it was, the prisoner would be sentenced to two years' imprisonment with hard labour.
Source: CITY POLICE COURT. (1875, January 15). The Mercury, Hobart p. 2.
Link: https://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article8934680

Garforth's Court and Prison Records 1865-1878
Name:Garford, Charles
Record Type:Convicts
Also known as:Pollock, John
Ship:Antipodes
Remarks: Free to colony. Tried Hobart Oct 1865
Index number:80430
Record ID:NAME_INDEXES:1394413
Archives Office of Tasmania
Link: https://stors.tas.gov.au/CON37-1-10$init=CON37-1-10p273
Link: https://stors.tas.gov.au/CON94-1-1

ALIAS 1865 John Pollock
Link: https://stors.tas.gov.au/CON37-1-10$init=CON37-1-10P273
Link: https://stors.tas.gov.au/CON94-1-1$init=CON94-1-1P338
Link: https://stors.tas.gov.au/CON94-1-1$init=CON94-1-1P339



Recorded as John Pollock, alias Charles Garforth
Source: Archives Office of Tasmania
Link:https://stors.tas.gov.au/CON37-1-10$init=CON37-1-10p273



Source: Archives Office of Tasmania
Link: https://stors.tas.gov.au/CON94-1-1 Image 338, p. 157

Charles Garforth, the name used as his real name by police in later convictions,is listed as his alias here, and John Pollock is the name under which he was sentenced to 4 years for larceny on 24 October 1865, per ship Antipodes, and sent to Port Arthur, arriving there on 10 November 1865. This is an error corrected in red ink: although John Pollock is still listed as his name, and Charles Garforth as his alias, the note in red states he was free to to the colony. The note also states he was discharged to the private service of Mr. Will Todd.

1873: 8 years for housebreaking
Court Records
Archives Office of Tasmania
Link: https://stors.tas.gov.au/SC32-1-9$init=SC32-1-9P184
Link: https://stors.tas.gov.au/AB693-1-1$init=AB693-1-1_103
Link: https://stors.tas.gov.au/SC32-1-9$init=SC32-1-9P185
Imprisoned for 8 years
Garfoot, Charles
Record Type: Court
Status: Free by servitude
Trial date: 18 Feb 1873
Place of trial: Hobart
Offense: Housebreaking and larceny
Verdict: Guilty
Prosecutions Project ID: 113654
Record ID: NAME_INDEXES:1521254
Resource: AB693-1-1 1873
SC32-1-9 Image 163
SC32-1-9 Image 164
The Prosecutions Project



Police gazette, 28th January to 3rd February 1873: Charles Garfoot, free in service, was sentenced to 8 years imprisonment for housebreaking.



1875: Garforth alias Pollock

REPORTS OF CRIME
8 January 1875
WARRANTS ISSUED, AND NOW IN THIS OFFICE.

HOBART TOWN.—On the 8th instant, by William Tarleton, Esquire, J.P., for the arrest of Charles J. Garforth, alias Pollock, charged with having, on or about the 4th instant at Hobart Town, fraudulently embezzled the sum of twelve pounds fourteen shillings and four pence, the property of the Tasmanian Government.

Description. About 45 years of age, 5 feet 9 inches, high, dark eyes, dark hair, black grizzly whiskers, thin features, smart appearance, a clerk. Formerly employed as constable and clerk at Port Arthur, and lately as clerk at Cascades, a Yorkshireman.
Source: POL 709/1, Archives Office of Tasmania

So what happened next? Did Garforth carry out his threat to make Boyd pay dearly?
Charles Garforth/Garfitt was discharged from the Hobart Gaol on 28 August 1878. Two years later, on 14 December 1880, he was tried again at the Supreme Court Hobart for breaking and entering a dwelling. He was discharged from the Hobart Gaol on 12 December 1885. Presumably, his threat to make A. H. Boyd pay dearly for a betrayal of trust as he saw it, which sentenced him to two years' hard labour in 1875 on Boyd's testimony, did not eventuate, at least not in the public domain. Charles Garforth was certainly not the first to express hatred of A. H. Boyd, nor indeed the last. A. H. Boyd was despised by the public throughout his career - as administrator of the Orphan School where he was dismissed for misogyny (1864), as Commandant of the Port Arthur Penitentiary where he was forced to resign for embezzlement of Public Works funds (1873), and as a short-lived administrator of the Cascades Asylum for Paupers where he was again reviled by staff and feared by inmates (1875-1877) - evidence of which proliferates in Parliamentary Papers seeking his dismissal, and in newspaper articles of the day decrying his bullying of staff and misuse of public funds. He died while drunk in a fall from his horse at Franklin (1827-1891). But he lived on the hopes of his descendants who wished to bring him up from history smelling of roses in the 1980s with an "artist photographer" attribution of the so-called "convict portraits, Port Arthur" (NLA ). Those original mugshots were correctly recognized and authenticated, of course, as the work of government contractor Thomas J. Nevin until Boyd's apologists sought his redemption. No photographs by A. H. Boyd are known or extant: he did NOT photograph prisoners, nor indeed anyone or anything in any other genre (KLW Imprint 2007, KLW NFC Group 2024, Kerr & Stilwell, 1995).

Marriage and children

1861: arrival of Mary Ann Larken (var. Larkens, Larking)
Mary Ann Larking arrived at Hobart, Tasmania on 26 October 1861 on board the bounty ship Antipodes with 102 other female immigrants. She married Charles Garforth in June 1862.

Bounty ship Antipodes 1861

Arrival of 103 female immigrants on the Antipodes
Mercury Monday 21 October 1861, page 2

TRANSCRIPT
SHIPPING.
ARRIVED.
October 19.-Antipodes, barque, 593 tons, G. Croot, from London, the 11th July, with general cargo. Cabin passengers, - Mrs. Croot, Capt. Harries, Mr. Dinham, M.R.C.S., and 103 female immigrants in the intermediate and steerage. Agent, McNaughtan and Co.



Name: Larking, Mary Ann
Record Type: Arrivals
Arrival date: 26 Oct 1861
Ship: Antipodes
Record ID: NAME_INDEXES:1469883
Resource: CB7/12/1/10 p201-202
Archives Office of Tasmania
Link: https://stors.tas.gov.au/37508688-5c26-45f0-ab79-10426a040992

1862: Marriage to Mary Ann Larken (var. Larkens, Larking)
Charles Garforth was 32 years old, a bachelor and a policeman when he married 22 year old bounty immigrant Mary Ann Larken at New Town on 26 June 1862.



Garforth, Charles John
Record Type: Marriages
Gender: Male
Age: 32
Spouse: Larken, Mary Ann
Gender: Female
Age: 22
Date of marriage: 26 Jun 1862
Registered: Hobart
Registration year: 1862
Record ID: NAME_INDEXES:862131
Resource: RGD37/1/21 no 216
Archives Office Tasmania
Link: https://stors.tas.gov.au/RGD37-1-21$init=RGD37-1-21P122

1862: birth of daughter Mira
Charles Garforth's occupation was listed as seaman when the birth of this child, Mira Catherine, was registered by a friend in September 1862.

.

Name: Garforth, Mira Catherine
Record Type: Births
Gender: Female
Father: Garforth, Charles
Mother: Larkins, Mary
Date of birth: 10 Sep 1862
Registered: Hobart
Registration year: 1862
Record ID: NAME_INDEXES:966964
Resource: RGD33/1/8 no 5444
Archives Office Tasmania
Link: https://stors.tas.gov.au/RGD33-1-8$init=RGD33-1-8-P270J2K

1864: birth of son John
Charles Garforth was listed as a mariner of Warwick St Hobart when his son John Garforth was born on 9 October 1864.



Garforth, John Edward
Record Type: Births
Gender: Male
Father: Garforth, Charles John
Mother: Mary, Ann
Date of birth: 09 Oct 1864
Registered: Hobart
Registration year: 1864
Record ID: NAME_INDEXES:1064763
Resource: RGD32/1/4 no 5878
Source: Archives Office of Tasmania
Link: https://stors.tas.gov.au/RGD32-1-4$init=RGD32-1-4P44

1866: son and daughter admitted to Orphan School
A daughter Catherine Garforth (b. 10 Dec. 1863), and a son John Garforth (b. 9 October 1864), were admitted to the Queens Orphan School on 1 st June 1866, application made by their mother Mary Ann Garforth, address Goodwin Court, Molle St. Hobart.



Garforth, Catherine
Garforth, John
Record Type: Health & Welfare
Description: Application for admission 1 June 1866; father Charles Garforth or Pollock, mother Mary Ann Larkins
Property: Queen's Orphan School
Record ID:NAME_INDEXES:1473490
Resource:SWD26/1/9 Image 291 (5 pages)
Source: Archives Office of Tasmania
Link: https://stors.tas.gov.au/SWD26-1-9$init=SWD26-1-9P292

1871: unnamed female birth
An unnamed female child was born to the couple and registered on 24 March 1871. Charles Garforth's occupation was listed as constable, Port Arthur. The birth was registered by an aunt of the child, Isabella Downes.



Garforth, Given Name Not Recorded
Record Type: Births
Gender: Female
Father: Garforth, Charles
Mother: Larkin, Mary Ann
Date of birth: 15 Feb 1871
Registered: Tasman
Registration year: 1871
Record ID: NAME_INDEXES:931332
Resource: RGD33/1/49 no 1668
Source: Archives Office of Tasmania
Link: https://stors.tas.gov.au/83ba670a-ee45-42df-9cfb-1d5455204a8e

1873: unnamed male birth
An unnamed male child was born to the couple while still working at Port Arthur as a clerk.



Garforth, Given Name Not Recorded
Record Type: Births
Gender: Male
Father: Garforth, Charles John
Mother: Larkin, Mary Ann
Date of birth: 20 May 1873
Registered: Tasman
Registration year: 1873 Record ID: NAME_INDEXES:942719
Resource: RGD33/1/51 no 1729
Source: Archives Office of Tasmania
Link: https://stors.tas.gov.au/a85d62fc-191e-472c-9a09-20319cd8e076

1875: son John admitted to Boy's Home
A son, John Edward Garforth, was born to Charles Garforth and Mary Ann Larken [sic] on 9 October 1864. In 1875, the ten year old child was admitted to the Kennerly Boys Home because his father, 44 years old, was serving a two year prison term for larceny. The child was discharged to his mother on 1st September 1876.



Archives Office Tasmania
Garforth, John Edward
Record Type: Health & Welfare
Age: 10 years, 4 months
Father: Garforth, Charles John Mother: Garforth, Mary Ann
Father occupation: Steward
Property: Kennerley Boys Home
Admission dates: 05 Feb 1875
File number: 50
Record ID: NAME_INDEXES:1777095
Resource: NS6493-1-1_052
Source: Archives Office of Tasmania
Link: https://stors.tas.gov.au/NS6493-1-1$init=NS6493-1-1_052

1875: birth of Lucy
Lucy was born in April, three months after her father was imprisoned in January 1875. His occupation was listed as clerk.



Name: Garforth, Lucy Henrietta
Record Type: Births
Gender: Female
Father: Garforth, Charles John
Mother: Mary, Ann
Date of birth: 12 Apr 1875
Registered: Hobart
Registration year: 1875 Record ID: NAME_INDEXES:976728
Resource: RGD33/1/11/ no 1132
Archives Office of Tasmania
Link: https://stors.tas.gov.au/RGD33-1-11$init=RGD33-1-11-P611

1875: Mary Ann Garforth and Richard Kirby
With her husband Charles Garforth serving two years at the Hobart Gaol, sentenced in January 1875, his wife Mary Ann Garforth  was residing at Elphinstone Street, Hobart by August 1875 in a house with garden, stores, sheds and stables owned and occupied by Richard Kirby. Charles Garforth was released with remission of his two year sentence on 13 November 1876. On 14 December 1880 he was tried again at the Supreme Court Hobart for breaking and entering a dwelling.  He was discharged from the Hobart Gaol on 12 December 1885.



Source: TASMANIA. LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL.
VALUATION OF PROPERTY. HOBART TOWN AND LAUNCESTON.
REPORT OF THE COMMISSIONERS.
Laid upon the Table by Mr. Chapman, and ordered by the Council to be printed, August 10, 1875.
Source: Parliament of Tasmania
Link: https://www.parliament.tas.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0023/36149/lc1875pp43.pdf


RELATED POSTS main weblog